In a significant legal development, a judge has recently imposed fines exceeding $50 million upon California for its persistent failure to address the severe shortage of mental health providers within the state’s prison system.
Mental Health Crisis Fine Exceed $50 Million
More than $50 million fines, handed down by Chief U.S. District Judge Kimberly Mueller, are a result of a long-standing federal class action lawsuit, which has been ongoing for decades, addressing the treatment of mentally ill inmates in California.
Governor’s Focus on Mental Health Reform
Despite Governor Gavin Newsom making a substantial effort to overhaul the state’s mental health system during his second term, his office has refrained from commenting on the understaffing issues, citing ongoing litigation. Meanwhile, Newsom is advocating for voter support to pass a $6.4 billion bond measure in March, aimed at adding thousands of new behavioral health beds across the state.
Inmate Plaintiffs’ Perspective
Ernest Galvan, an attorney representing the inmate plaintiffs in the lawsuit, emphasizes the importance of expanding treatment options within the community for long-term success. However, he notes that the state must also meet the immediate needs of the mentally ill population.
California, under court order, has managed to reduce its prison population from approximately 136,000 to 92,000 over the past decade. Despite this reduction, the percentage of incarcerated individuals with mental illness continues to rise.
A Disturbing History
Under the case, known as Coleman, a federal court ruled in 1995 that the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation failed to provide adequate mental health care to prisoners. The court found that the department’s mental health staff were “stretched dangerously thin,” leading to a decline in the quality of treatment, a decrease in the number of treated inmates, and an alarming number of in-custody suicides.
Elusive Compliance
In 2009, the state’s corrections department submitted a comprehensive plan to guide an overhaul of its mental health care system, with the court appointing a special master to monitor compliance. However, nearly 15 years later, Judge Mueller has determined that the state has been unable to meet its targets and the maximum 10% job vacancy rate mandated by the court.
Challenges in Staffing
Terri Hardy, a spokesperson for the state corrections department, acknowledges the shortage of providers and highlights the challenge posed by the remote locations of many state prisons, which historically make them difficult to staff.
Also Read: Climate Advocacy Groups Urge Governor Newsom to Investigate California’s Transportation Department
Fines Imposed: The Calculations
Judge Mueller initiated the imposition of fines in April, calculated based on the money saved by the corrections department due to unfilled yet budgeted mental health positions. The fines are computed monthly, taking into account the average maximum salary for each vacant position, with clinical psychologists and social workers experiencing the highest vacancy rates and incurring the most substantial fines.
Assessing Compliance
This month’s trial primarily focused on one central question: whether the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation had taken all reasonable measures to address its mental health staffing shortages and comply with the court’s 90% staffing mandate.
State’s Efforts and Challenges
The state argued that the corrections department had made “extraordinary efforts” to maintain staffing levels, citing higher-than-average salaries, expanded telework options, and new labor agreements with salary increases and other financial incentives.
Inmates’ Urgent Plea
However, the inmates’ attorneys contested these claims, maintaining that the state had not acted urgently enough to fill the positions and had continued with “business as usual.” They argued that the salaries offered to psychologists and social workers in California prisons fell far short of compensating them for the challenging working conditions they faced.
Seeking Resolution
While the state has requested more time to come into compliance, the inmates’ attorneys have urged Judge Mueller to issue a contempt ruling and order the state to pay the full amount of fines, emphasizing the urgency of addressing the ongoing mental health crisis within California’s prisons.
